In Dexter®: Resurrection Season 2, Episode 4, “Young Blood” now streaming on Paramount+ (Paramount+ Premium plan),  Dexter Morgan (Michael C. Hall) confronts questions about his Code as he sizes up a potential target. Meanwhile, Harrison (Jack Alcott) gets a chance to prove himself in the field.

Spoiler warning: The following is a recap – a recap with spoilers! Want a spoiler-free experience? Stream the episode now, then return here bloody fast to see if we caught anything you missed. 

WATCH NOW: Dexter®: Resurrection Season 2, Episode 4, “Young Blood” 

Key facts

  • Series: Dexter®: Resurrection
  • Season: 2
  • Episode: 4, “Young Blood”
  • Air date: Nov. 20, 2026
  • Genre: Crime drama/Thriller
  • Streaming platform: Paramount+ (Paramount+ Premium plan)
  • Episode recap: Dexter weighs a tough decision involving his next potential victim, while Harrison steps up in an unexpected way.
  • Spoilers: Yes,  this recap contains spoilers for Season 2, Episode 4.
Watch On Paramount+

Recap summary: What happens in “Young Blood”

Paramount+

In the Dexter®: Resurrection episode “Young Blood,” Dexter Morgan scans the file provided for him by Charley (Uma Thurman), former assistant to Leon Prater (Peter Dinklage) and facilitator to this eccentric billionaire’s serial killer gatherings. In this file is information about the last surviving member of Prater’s club, the JawSplitter. This criminal drains the blood of his young male victims, infuses it into his own body, and keeps the jawbones as macabre souvenirs. A charmer, to be sure. 

Harrison (Jack Alcott) knocks at his father’s apartment door bearing bagels, and Dexter’s first inclination is to hide his research. But he rethinks this impulse. This is a new era, after all. One of communication and connection. He therefore allows his son to see the grisly documents and expresses his intentions to slay the mandible-removing monster. 

Only a couple of hours remain before Dexter’s big kill when he receives a call from P.I. Joey Quinn (Desmond Harrington). Joey admits to his former Miami Metro colleague that he’s stumped. Ever since Dexter directed him to George, would-be victim of the Sleepy-Eyed Stranger, Joey has been trying to figure out why a notorious serial killer would leave a man alive and shackled inside a U-Haul van. This was not the Sleepy-Eyed Stranger’s usual M.O. Did his change of routine have anything to do with a Prater rendezvous, or with Prater’s apparent link to a real estate group that owns a slew of Manhattan townhouses?

Dexter is uncomfortable with how close Joey is getting to the truth. He tells his old buddy that the theory sounds crazy, hoping to throw Joey off the scent. Besides, Dexter can’t be entertaining such crazy notions right now – not when he’s about to be late for an appointment to stab one of Prater’s serial killer club-members at a swanky townhouse …

Dexter and Charley arrive early at the apartment so that Charley can brief her partner on what to expect when the JawSplitter arrives; this predator is the type of guy who tries every age-defying treatment and surgery on the market. Dexter ought to prepare himself for any and every manner of face that could arrive at the doorstep. Shockingly, the face that does arrive is that of a 22-year-old – an actual 22-year-old. This is the son of the JawSplitter, J.J. (Jack Dylan Grazer), who states that his dad has been dead for a few years, and that the last handful of  “jaw-splittings” have actually been his handiwork. 

Having long known about his father’s hobby, as well as Prater’s serial-killer soiree, JJ implores Charley and Dexter to allow him into the murderers’ club. After all, he’s proven that he can both take lives and keep Prater’s big secret. Privately, Dexter and Charley debate whether or not JJ should receive the fate Dexter had planned for the elder JawSplitter. Dexter determines that he needs to spend a little more time with the kid before he’ll know for certain whether JJ meets the criteria of Harry’s Code – that is, the rules his adoptive father established to govern whom Dexter can kill. 

At first, JJ seems more like a victim than a cold-blooded killer. His father introduced him to his horrifying pastime when JJ was just 14, and the boy received little attention from Dad unless he participated in murder or allowed the man to draw the youngster’s blood for bizarre anti-aging rituals. But Dexter has Harrison do a background check and learns that the wide-eyed JJ actually has a sealed juvie record. Dexter also discovers that the JawSplitter did not die of natural causes; JJ decided he was ready to take up the JawSplitter mantle and consequently eliminated the old fellow, extracting his jaw for good measure. 

This information is enough for Dexter to conclude that JJ has had sociopathic tendencies for years, and that – even if he didn’t share his pop’s love of violence as a teen – he certainly delights in it now. Dexter slips his trusty syringe into JJ’s neck and transports him to his kill table, where he readily stabs the young man in the heart. After disposing of the remains, Dexter delivers a bottle of bubbly to Charley’s hotel room, excited to celebrate a successful collaboration. But Charley is already packed and ready to take the next flight out of New York. Dexter’s hopes for a continued partnership — professional or otherwise — are dashed. Was he wrong to believe that letting someone in was worth the risk?

As Dexter mopes, the Five Borough Killer (Dan Stevens) is busy announcing his third kill-location to the NYPD: the subway. Captain Mixon (Bokeem Woodbine) stations cops on as many subway cars as possible. His daughter Fiona (Nona Parker Johnson), training officer and one-time one-night stand to Harrison is posted alongside her trainee when the twosome notices a delinquent stealing an old woman’s handbag. Together, they overpower the man and recover the property. Fiona gains a newfound respect for Harrison’s abilities, and the duo celebrates the takedown with a drink … and a second-night stand. 

. 

But while a thief has been stopped in his tracks, the Five Borough Killer remains at large. He has slipped poison into a bottle of water and handed it to a homeless man, who has dropped dead after taking a sip – mere feet from a pair of subway-stationed police officers. The killer then AirDrops footage of the murder to the NYPD, mocking the cops for failing to stop a crime committed right under their noses.

Harrison tells Dexter that he feels helpless against predators like the Five Borough Killer and the New York Ripper (Brian Cox), another notorious murderer that the police can’t seem to bring to justice. Even with so much technology and weaponry and manpower at their disposal, the NYPD can’t take these scourges of the Earth down. Maybe Dexter’s way is the right way. Harrison thinks so, and he gives his father his blessing to take out the New York Ripper, a task he initially wanted Dexter to leave to the cops. 

Dexter knows he should keep his murderous proclivities separate from Harrison’s police work. He’s already crossed a line by asking his son to look up information on JJ, and he doesn’t want to further blur the boundaries between their respective pursuits. That said, how he’d love to plunge a blade into the Ripper’s chest …

Just as he’s considering this opportunity, there’s a knock at his door. If the surprise on Dexter’s face is any indication, the visitor is a major blast from his past. Perhaps a brand new partnership is right around the corner. 

Key moments and takeaways

In one of the episode’s most revealing moments, Dexter prepares for a visit with Charley by selecting some fancy booze from his makeshift kill room and fussing with his hair outside her hotel room. He even takes his glasses on and off, considering which look might make the better impression.

Throughout their partnership, Dexter and Charley have exchanged flirtatious texts, complete with pet names, to throw off anyone who might glimpse their messages. Better to look like lovebirds than a serial killer and Prater’s former right-hand woman plotting to snuff out some notorious predators. But as the two have gradually let down their emotional guards, Dexter has begun to believe that Charley shares his enthusiasm for their alliance – and perhaps even his romantic interest.

So when Charley opens her hotel room door with her suitcase packed and a plane waiting to take her away, Dexter is stunned. Not only does his partner in crime have no interest in continuing their professional relationship, but Dexter questions whether the personal revelations they’ve shared meant as much to her as they did to him. Perhaps those flirtatious texts were nothing more than a cover story. Could Charley’s emotional openness simply have been a way to get him to lower his guard.

Dexter isn’t necessarily ready to abandon his newfound appreciation for human connection, but Charley’s departure delivers a blow to his confidence in it. The next time someone offers him a chance at closeness, he may not be so quick to take it.

Character highlights

Harrison is growing disenchanted with the NYPD’s inability to bring criminals to justice, especially compared with his father’s recent successes. The rookie cop has earned praise for chasing down and overpowering a thief, but he can’t take the same approach with the New York Ripper or the Five Borough Killer. There are procedures to follow, evidence to gather, i’s to dot and t’s to cross. Increasingly frustrated by the limitations of police work, Harrison begins to wish he could handle these murderers the way he handled that thief – or the way Dexter handles his targets. The Morgan who once insisted on doing things by the book and keeping his work separate from his dad’s pursuits suddenly seems a little more receptive to Dexter’s vigilante methods.

Charley, too, is growing disillusioned with the life she’s built for herself. She’s in this frame of mind when she meets Joey Quinn for drinks. The PI has discovered the late Angel Batista’s (David Zayas) favorite hat among Prater’s stash of serial killer souvenirs in the NYPD evidence room, and he suspects Charley knows more about the collection than she’s let on. Though all charges against Charley have been dropped, Joey is convinced she’s clued into Prater’s activities – and perhaps has answers about what happened to his longtime friend. 

Charley urges Joey to let the matter go and walk away, but she might as well be speaking to herself. Though she’s toyed with the idea of continuing her partnership with Dexter and helping him bring down even more serial killers, the conversation with Joey seems to remind Charley of the dangers of that world. She’s already managed to escape it once. Her brief return may have been an attempt to atone for her past, but schmoozing with murderers any longer could undo everything she’s worked to leave behind.

What’s next on Dexter®: Resurrection

A familiar face from Dexter’s past resurfaces, challenging his beliefs and reshaping his next move. Meanwhile, as Harrison takes on greater responsibility within the NYPD, the hunt for the Five Borough Killer intensifies across New York.

Don’t miss what happens next on Dexter®: Resurrection when Season 2, Episode 5 premieres Friday, Nov. 27, on Paramount+ for Premium plan subscribers.

Dexter®: Resurrection

Dexter®: Resurrection

Watch Now

Joan Kubicek

Joan Kubicek

Staff Writer

See more by Joan Kubicek